Grades Are In

It's that time of year again. The final grades are in. The Red Sox beat writer from the Boston Herald, Michael Silverman, has published his 2008 Red Sox regular season Report Card. Who went to the Head of the Class? Who flunked out?

Not surprisingly, Silverman gave the top grade of A to: Dustin Pedroia, Kevin Youkilis, John Lester, Terry Francona, and Theo Epstein. All 3 of those players had career years this season, and Pedroia and Youkilis are the top canditates for not just team MVP, but AL MVP. Lester has emerged as a potential ace, nicely picking up the slack from Josh Beckett's performance that was muddied due to injuries. Francona may be the best manager in Red Sox history. He's lead the Red Sox to the play-offs in 4 of his 5 seasons in Boston, winning it all in 2004 and 2007. I think his grade here stems from the Manny circus he had to manage through and around and how he was able to keep the team focused in the aftermath of that mess. Theo's grade seems to stem from the results from the Manny trade, along with the key additions of Paul Byrd and Mark Kotsay down the stretch. Let's take a look at the rest of the grades:

A- Grade
Jason Bay
Javier Lopez
Justin Masterson
Daisuke Matsuzaka
Jonathan Papelbon

B+ Grade
Sean Casey
Jacoby Ellsbury
Jed Lowrie
Manny Delcarmen
Hideki Okajima

B Grade
Coco Crisp
Mark Kotsay
Tim Wakefield

B- Grade
Kevin Cash
Mike Lowell
Josh Beckett
Paul Byrd

C+ Grade
Alex Cora
J.D. Drew
David Ortiz

C- Grade
Jason Varitek
David Aardsma

D+ Grade
Mike Timlin

D Grade
Julio Lugo

D- Grade
Clay Buchholz

F Grade
Bartolo Colon

For the most part, I think these are right on. Varitek's grade appears to be a bit high. He was terrible at the plate. However, most of his grade stems from his handling of pitchers. That is a thing that really can't be quantified and too me is a bit overrated. Varitek gets a lot of the credit with Lester's success and catching 4 no-hitters over his career, but when Buchholz didn't perform this season falls more on Buchholz than Varitek. I'm not saying Varitek takes any credit, just talking about how the sportwriters/"experts" give credit.

Finally, Silverman did take a cheap shot by putting Colon in here with an F-grade. Which he admits in his blurb:

"It's a good thing Colon appeared in the second half, even it was only for one start, since it gives us an excuse to rip his makeup. Any player who decides he is too big - we will pass on the obvious rip opportunity - to accept a different role (Colon was asked to pitch out of the bullpen) is a small-minded prima donna."

I don't really remember too much said about this at the time. In fact, I don't even remember reading or hearing about the team asking Colon to move to the bullpen and him declining. But, it wasn't a big deal at the time, and quite frankly I think, based on his performance, that it wouldn't have worked out with bringing him out of the bullpen.

I can't wait for Wednesday night. What a long too days with out any Red Sox baseball. Although, back-to-back win to move on baseball games is fun.

Go Sox!